16 books that are better together: 8 terrific novels paired with 8 illuminating nonfiction picks to elevate your reading experience

16 books that are better together: 8 terrific novels paired with 8 illuminating nonfiction picks to elevate your reading experience

I love a good wine flight, yet I’m much more comfortable in the world of books—and so I really love a good book flight. While I frequently read books willy-nilly, prioritizing the new, the recently recommended, or whatever reserve request just came in at the library, I’ve found there are real advantages to purposeful literary match-ups.

It’s the time of year when sports fans—plus a whole bunch of people who, eleven months of the year, couldn’t care less—turn their attention to college basketball.

What’s so great about March Madness? The match-ups. As readers, we know all about the importance of a strategic pairing. So over the next four weeks we’re hosting our own Book Flight Bonanza to bring a whole bunch of great book match-ups—or, in our terms, book flights— your way. 32 pairings, to be exact, for a total of 64 fantastic books.

To stay on top of each week’s picks and get access to your updated printable “brackets” (to serve as your shopping/library list), subscribe below. Print your brackets, grab your highlighter, and start planning what you want to read next. Subscribers will get those printables in their inbox automatically with each new Book Flight Bonanza post.

That’s the blank “bracket” above. We’re kicking off our reading festivities today, filling in our first “region” with eight flights (that’s sixteen books) that pair terrific novels with illuminating nonfiction.

great alone into the wild

Alaskan adventure gone wrong

The Great Alone by Kristin Hannah
Into the Wild by Jon Krakauer

I inhaled Kristin Hannah’s long-anticipated new release about a family struggling for physical and emotional survival in the Alaskan wilderness. Hannah writes, “There’s a saying: Up here you can make one mistake. The second one will kill you.” It’s so good—we’ll be reading it in the MMD Book Club this summer. Pair this with Krakauer’s pageturner about a young man who wanted to live the unadorned life in the Alaskan, and who made his second mistake just 16 weeks after entering the Alaskan bush.

Click here to buy The Great Alone: Amazon | B & N
Click here to buy Into the Wild: Amazon | B & N

Love and Justice

An American Marriage by Tayari Jones
Just Mercy: A Story of Justice and Redemption by Bryan Stevenson

Jones’s newly-released novel is getting all the love for all the right reasons: she turns the racial injustice of mass incarceration—which she has called the “most pressing civil rights issue of our day”—into the backdrop of a novel about how that injustice impacts the experience of being black in America today. Roy and Celestial have been married a year when he is convicted for a crime he didn’t commit. He is eventually released, but the consequences remain devastating.

This pairs superbly with Stevenson’s nonfiction, story-driven account of his work with the Equal Justice Initiative, which defends the wrongly accused, addresses why these false convictions happen in the first place, and offers solutions for how to change that.

Click here to buy An American Marriage: Amazon | B & N
Click here to buy Just Mercy: A Story of Justice and Redemption: Amazon | B & N

Enigmatic Russian Royalty

I Was Anastasia: A Novel by Ariel Lawhon
The Romanov Sisters by Helen Rappaport

In 1920 Germany, a woman named Anna Anderson was pulled out of a canal in Germany, claiming to be Anastasia Romanov, and bearing the scars of a violent attack. In her latest historical novel, Lawhon uses an unusual structure to tell both stories, that of Anna Anderson (going backwards in time, from 1970), and that of Anastasia Romanov (beginning in 1917 when the family is taken prisoner, and moving forward in time). When the two stories converge, all is revealed.

Helen Rappaport’s bestselling and highly-rated history about the four Romanov daughters and their mother makes an excellent companion.

Click here to preorder I Was Anastasia (coming March 27): Amazon | B & N
Click here to buy The Romanov Sisters: Amazon | B & N

Love, War, and Belonging

News of the World by Paulette Jiles
Tribe: On Homecoming and Belonging by Sebastian Junger

Jiles tells a spare story of two unlikely friends—one a retired Civil War captain, one a ten-year-old girl rescued from the Indians who captured her as a babe. It’s indexed as a Western, but if that genre makes you want to run and hide, have no fear. More than anything, this is a story about family—the kind you’re born to, and the kind you make.

Junger’s nonfiction work explores loyalty, belonging, and our shared quest for meaning, and these themes match perfectly with News of the World. This slim work is pithy, insightful, and paradigm shifting.

Click here to buy News of the World: Amazon | B & N
Click here to buy Tribe: Amazon | B & N

Oklahoma’s Tumultuous Past

Dreamland Burning by Jennifer Latham
Killers of the Flower Moon: The Osage Murders and the Birth of the FBI by David Grann

Lathan’s well-crafted YA release smoothly bridges the divide between present-day Tulsa, Oklahoma and the little-known race riots that occurred there during two terrifying days in 1921. Latham’s story flips back and forth in time, between two teens of mixed descent living a century apart, but who each face their own kinds of crossroads, giving readers a page-turning history/mystery mash-up, as her young protagonists wrestle through issues of family, friendship, and identity.

Gramm’s true crime story reads like a thriller, and addresses a theme we see throughout Dreamland Burning: the identity, heritage, and wealth of the Osage Indian nation. In 1920s Oklahoma, members were among the richest people in the world, thanks to the vast oil reserves that lay beneath their reservation. But during the period of 1921-1926, more than two dozen Osage died suspiciously in the “Reign of Terror,” and when corrupt local law enforcement repeatedly bungled their cases, J. Edgar Hoover came in, making a case for a national, more professional police force in the process.

Click here to buy Dreamland Burning: Amazon | B & N
Click here to buy Killers of the Flower Moon: Amazon | B & N

Katrina heartbreak

Salvage the Bones by Jesmyn Ward
Five Days at Memorial by Sherri Fink

Ward’s National Book Award-winning novel follows a Mississippi family living in dire poverty during the twelve days leading up to Hurricane Katrina and its aftermath. Ward’s beautiful prose contrasts starkly with the pain and grit of her story, though she doesn’t leave her characters—or her readers—without hope.

Pair this with Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Fink’s meticulous account of exactly what went down in the aftermath of Katrina in one specific place: Memorial Medical Center in New Orleans. It’s a real pageturner, so good and so readable—but the content will make you want to weep for humanity. (Read it anyway.)

Click here to buy Salvage the Bones: Amazon | B & N
Click here to buy Five Days at Memorial: Amazon | B & N

Taking flight

Circling the Sun: A Novel by Paula McClain
West With the Night by Beryl Markham

In the spirit of her debut The Paris Wife, McClain’s biographical novel chronicles the life of Beryl Markham, who is best known for her 1936 solo flight across the Atlantic. Markham was the daughter of British colonials, raised in East Africa’s Mau Forest “before Kenya was Kenya.” She’s known as an aviatrix, but McClain clearly relishes highlighting how Markham enjoyed flouting conventions of all kinds.

To hear the same story straight from the woman herself, pick up Markham’s 1942 memoir West with the Night, a book frequently called a must-read adventure story, and which Ernest Hemingway called “bloody wonderful.”

Click here to buy Circling the Sun: Amazon | B & N
Click here to buy West With the Night: Amazon | B & N

Public Mortification

Young Jane Young by Gabrielle Zevin
So You’ve Been Publicly Shamed by Jon Ronson

The Storied Life of A. J. Fikry author Gabrielle Zevin’s newest release probes serious issues yet is tons of fun to read: it’s the story of a young Congressional intern who sleeps with her boss, spurring a political scandal that ends her career, but not his. Thankfully, that’s just the beginning of the story, which unfolds through the eyes of three generations of affected women.

Ronson’s nonfiction work about public shaming in the social media era is an absorbing read that’s also more than a little terrifying for anyone who ever uses the internet.

Click here to buy Young Jane Young: Amazon | B & N
Click here to buy So You’ve Been Publicly Shamed: Amazon | B & N

Which pairing are you most excited to read? Can you think of any great match-ups to add to this list? Please tell us about them in comments!


  1. Lorraine says:

    Great match-ups! I have several of the matches in my TBR so I think I will in fact try to do them as pairings. I love this idea which first hit me last month when I posted about the An American Marriage/Just Mercy pairing on your Instagram-glad you agree that it’s a good one 🙂 As a bonus pick, I’d add The Sun Does Shine: How I Found Life and Freedom on Death Row by Anthony Ray Hinton, one of the people Bryan Stevenson helped and talks about in Just Mercy. I mentioned it in the same post-it’s out 3/27 and it’s so so good.

    • Tracie says:

      Thanks for the bonus pick on Just Mercy pairing–the Hinton book is on my WTR list, after having devoured Just Mercy (and having the privilege of hearing Bryan Stevenson speak in my area two weeks ago!).

  2. Karen says:

    I have “Taking Flight” on my TBR list already. Both are on my Kindle!

    A pairing I read last year was:
    Hidden Figures (Here’s so much more in the book than the movie!)
    The Rise of the Rocket Girls (Which covers the “girls” across the continent at the Jet Propulsion Lab (JPL) in Pasadena.
    It was interesting to read both since NASA & JPL were essentially rivals during much of that timeframe.

    (I’m following these up this year with Code Girls: The Untold Story of the American Women Code Breakers of WWII.)

  3. Leslie says:

    As someone who has trouble picking fiction reads outside of my few personally well loved aurhors (and who can easily burn out on back to back to back non fiction), these recommendations fascinate me! Thanks. (And apologies for the long sentence. 🙂

  4. Lisa says:

    Thank you – what a fun idea for a bookish March Madness! A Fact & Fiction pairing I read was Kristin Hannah’s The Nightingale and Resistance: A Frenchwoman’s Journal of the War, a diary by Agnes Humbert, a member of the French Resistance. Hannah mentions the diary in her notes at the end of The Nightingale. Both stories were amazing.

    • Lorraine Bachand says:

      Not a fiction pairing but I think When Breath Becomes Air or The Bright Hour: A Memoir of Living and Dying would be great with Being Mortal; real life experience and perspective from people living (and dying) the themes in that book.

    • Traci says:

      A fiction pairing that I think would be great with Being Mortal would be either of two books by Lisa Genova: Still Alice (about a woman who is a university professor and diagnosed with early onset Alzheimer’s Disease – it’s also been made into a movie), or her latest book, Every Note Played (will be published on March 20th) about a man who is a concert pianist and is diagnosed with ALS. Loved both of those books!

  5. Julia R. says:

    I absolutely love the idea of book flights and the pairing I’m most excited to read is Circling the Sun paired with West with the Night. Now, which one should I read first? 🙂

  6. Toni says:

    I’m curious if you have an opinion about whether to read the fiction or non-fiction first?

    I recently read Nothing to Envy: Ordinary Lives in North Korea, and thought it would be a great companion read to The Orphan Master’s Son, which I read a few years ago.

  7. Kristin says:

    I got on a roll last year and read Americanah, Born a Crime and The Hate U Give all together. I also just finished Homegoing which I think rounds put that flight nicely! All were very interesting with different perspectives on a similar topic.

    • Emily Johnson says:

      Kristin, I just finished Born a Crime and I’m halfway through The Hate U Give. And I’m on hold for Homegoing. We were thinking alike!!

  8. Julie R says:

    These are all fantastic! I think I naturally do lots of “book pairing” myself. When I read something I love, I usually find something else about that topic to read right away. I recently read The World of Laura Ingalls Wilder by Marta McDowell along with Caroline by Sarah Miller. Loved them both!

  9. Adrienne says:

    What a fabulous concept Anne! I’m on the waiting list at the library for ‘The Great Alone’ so will tackle ‘Into the Wild’ while I wait. Thank you!

  10. Tracie says:

    Being both a lover of books and college basketball, you couldn’t have created a more delightful “bracket” than this, Anne! Bracketology is a way of life in our house–coupled with reading great books! Wahoo–and whee!
    For another pairing suggestion, I would add “The Lilac Girls” (Martha Hall Kelly) and “A Train in Winter” (Caroline Moorehead).

  11. Cheryl says:

    Just finished reading Circling the Sun and recommended it to friends. Will read West with the Night to complete my first pairing.

  12. Heather says:

    And so my TBR list grows and grows. I love the idea of pairing fiction with fact, especially as I have a hard time finding nonfiction that draws me in. A couple of these (fictions) were already on my list, so I will add their pairings as well. Circling the Sun and West with the Night were on my radar from when you first mentioned them in a podcast, Anne. Also I am intrigued by I was Anastasia, so that makes a second pair.

  13. liz n. says:

    Another pairing for “The Nightingale”…

    “Wine & War” by Don and Petie Kladstrup, telling the story of French wineries, vintners, and townspeople who formed their own resistance group of sorts to protect French grape crops and wines from Nazi pillaging.

  14. SoCalLynn says:

    I am moving Paula McClain’s book up and adding Beryl Markham to my stack. I’ve been wanting to read both of these and now I can’t wait. This is such an excellent idea, well done!

  15. Susanne says:

    I just finished The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas. It is a MUST READ. When I finished it, I immediately began rereading. Now I am seriously considering pairing it with a reading of Tupac Shakur Legacy. (Keep in mind, I am a white, middle-aged woman in the rural south.)

    • Kyla Pearlman says:

      Good idea. I was also thinking about reading the Autobiography of Malcolm X to round out my (white, middle-aged) knowledge of the issues presented in The Hate U Give (amazing!)

  16. T. says:

    I’m interested. Looking into both titles in just a minute. Which first? I so love this concept of pairing, bracketology, flights. Two thoughts: 1. Seems to me that there should be a suggested wine for each pairing… or a suggested basketball game to match each! 2. For each of these pairings, which is suggested as “read first”?

  17. Amy Sloan says:

    I’m so excited to see this! A friend and I were recently discussing “book pairings” on my blog’s facebook page, and we thought we were so original… I guess not so much. 😉 Our original pairing linked 2 works of fiction; I like your concept of pairing fiction with nonfiction. I will have to link to your post on our original facebook “Book pairings: it’s not just for wine and cheese anymore” discussion. 🙂

  18. Byrd says:

    I read Travels with Zenobia (diary of Rose Wilder Lane during a trip to Armenia) followed by A Wilder Rose by Susan Wittig Albert back to back and it was amazing how Albert just continued her voice from the diary right into her book (it chronologically follows the diary). The diary can be hard to find – I had to ILL it.

  19. Kyla Pearlman says:

    Interesting that although I usually read fiction, of the pairs listed here that I’ve read, I preferred the non-fiction in every case (Tribe, Killers of the Flower Moon, and So You’ve Been Publicly Shamed). I should read more non-fiction! And I love the idea of pairing fiction and non-fiction. Amazing.

  20. Adrienne says:

    Here’s a suggested pairing for medical history buffs! Pair
    ‘A Fierce Radiance’ by Lauren Belfer, which is a fascinating novel about the early attempts to learn how to use penicillin to treat infections and also touches on the difficulties in scaling up production of the newly-discovered wonder drug. There is also a fascinating look at how attempts were made to extract antibiotics out of soils and purify them for use. I’d suggest pairing this with ‘The Mold in Dr. Florey’s Coat’ which is a historical account of Howard Florey and the work he and his team did that took the next step beyond Fleming’s observations about how the mold affected bacterial colonies.

  21. Tara says:

    I recently finished In the Kingdom of Ice: The Grand and Terrible Polar Voyage of the USS Jeannette and thought it would be a great pairing for Dan Simmons’ The Terror, which is a fictional account of a similar real-life ship voyage that really caught my imagination a couple of summers ago…and now is coming out as a mini-series on AMC!

  22. Megan Troxell says:

    Purely by chance I’m reading Another Day in the Death of America, Gary Younge (nonfiction) and Peace Like a River, Leif Enger, at the same time and they go so well together with the theme of gun violence and the impact on family/community. Didn’t plan it but it’s made each book more meaningful.

  23. Katie says:

    I just happen to have Young Jane Young, and So You’ve Been Publicly Shamed on my nightstand! So many of these book are already on my TBR list, I can’t wait to check them out with their recommended pairings.

  24. Judy H. says:

    Anne, I am indeed intrigued! I have never thought about book pairing before, what a challenging idea. You’ve captured me, I’m picking up Circling the Sun: A Novel and West With the Night right away. Equally challenging is thinking about books I would pair, I’m going to have to spend some time on that. Thank you for sharing this whole new way of looking at books and deciding which pair to read next!

  25. Molly says:

    Not a fiction/non-fiction pairing, but in January I started reading The Lady in Gold by Anne Marie O’Connor. About half way through I realized I had Monuments Men by Robert M. Edsel on my Kindle and began reading that simultaneously. I’ll have to try this pairing thing again in the future, because I really enjoyed how I got a fuller picture of the time period and topics.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.