Literary novels that ask audacious questions, with Lucy Tan

What Should I Read Next episode 550: Conversation-starting books and stories worth telling

a photo of an open book on top of a book stack

I always enjoys welcoming an author whose writing I’ve loved to the show to talk about all things books and reading. Lucy Tan’s 2018 debut, What We Were Promised, was one of my favorites, and I’ve been eagerly awaiting the follow up ever since. Lucy’s new book, Tiger’s Mouth, is out today, and if that title sounds familiar it may be because I recommended it as one of my favorite books of fall in this year’s Fall Book Preview. Today I’m welcoming Lucy to the show to talk all about it.

Together, we’ll explore Tiger’s Mouth: a story of two very different young men who meet as interns at a software company right out of college, and how their friendship, and later their rivalry, influences the course of their lives over decades. This book dives into themes both timeless and incredibly timely: the power of a life-changing friendship, AI equity and privacy, ambition and its costs, and the destructive force of a secret kept too long.

Lucy also works as a bookseller and the book buyer at Seattle’s Secret Garden Books. We’ll talk about how Lucy’s work has impacted what she loves to read, and also what and how she writes. Lucy enjoys reading and recommending books that don’t get much traditional media attention, with a special emphasis on foreign or translated fiction in her own reading life, as you’ll hear today.

We’d love to hear about the titles you think miss out on the media attention they deserve: Please leave a comment below to share your favorites.

Connect with Lucy Tan on Instagram and on her website. To get a signed copy of Tiger’s Mouth, order from Secret Garden Books and ask for signed/personalized in the order comments.

Hear more from authors in MMD Book Club!

If you’d like more conversations with authors in your reading life, one of our recurring features in our Modern Mrs Darcy Book Club is author chats with the writers of our monthly picks. We’ve shared a few of those conversations here on the podcast in the past, including talks with Brendan Slocumb, Thao Thai, and Kevin Wilson. Our November Book Club events include a one-hour intro to Louise Erdrich and her 2021 novel, The Sentence, as well as a member-driven class on coffee table books. We’re also looking ahead to Team Best Books of the Year event in early January, a special member-only event. Find out more and join us at ⁠modernmrsdarcy.com/club.⁠

[00:00:00] LUCY TAN: I think every reader's experience is unique and beautiful and different, and this is why we keep coming back to books. This is why we want to talk about them with each other.

ANNE BOGEL: Ooh, I also love a book that serves as a conversation starter.

Hey readers, I'm Anne Bogel, and this is What Should I Read Next?. Welcome to the show that's dedicated to answering the question that plagues every reader, what should I read next? We don't get bossy on this show. What we will do here is give you the information you need to choose your next read.

[00:00:39] Readers, today you'll be hearing from an author whose work I have loved. And if listening to your favorite authors is something you'd like more of in your reading life, our Modern Mrs. Darcy Book Club is the place to be. We have a nice range of offerings in Book Club, and one of our regular recurring features is author chats with the writers of our monthly picks.

We host authors almost every month in Book Club. We've actually shared a few of those conversations with you here on the podcast in the past, including talks with Brendan Slocumb, Thao Thai, and Kevin Wilson. If you'd like to hear what a Book Club author chat sounds like, and how it's different from a conversation like the one you'll hear today, any of those backlist episodes would be great to check out.

Book Club is the place where we're learning to read better together and having so much fun doing it. Our November events include a one-hour intro to Louise Erdrich and her 2021 novel, The Sentence, with the goal being to make your first read feel like a re-read, and a member-driven class on coffee table books.

[00:01:34] Pretty soon we'll be discussing our December pick, Every Day I Read, and looking ahead to our member-only Team Best Books of the Year event come first of the year. Find out more and join us at modernmrsdarcy.com/club. That's modernmrsdarcy.com/club.

Readers, it is always fun to have an author whose work I enjoy join me on the show to talk about all things books and reading. I read and loved Lucy Tan's debut, What We Were Promised, back when it was published in 2018, and ever since then, for years now, I've been checking regularly to see what she's up to and when she might have a new book coming out, and my efforts were finally rewarded. I pounced on her new novel, Tiger's Mouth, late this summer just as soon as I got my hands on my advance copy, and I enthusiastically recommended it as one of my favorite books of fall in this year's Fall Book Preview. So when the opportunity arose to talk with her on the show, I could not say yes fast enough. Lucy's new book, Tiger's Mouth, is out now, today, November 17th, if you're listening right when this episode comes out.

[00:02:39] Tiger's Mouth is a story of two very different young men who meet as interns at a software company right out of college. Tan explores the story of how their friendship, and later their rivalry, influences the course of their lives over decades. This book dives into themes both timeless and incredibly timely: the power of a life-changing friendship, AI equity and privacy, ambition and its costs, and the destructive force of a secret kept too long. I cannot wait to hear more about all of it from Lucy's point of view.

As you will hear, Lucy also works as a bookseller and the book buyer at Seattle's Secret Garden Books. I am eager to explore how her work has impacted what she loves to read, and also what and how she writes. Lucy has said she enjoys reading and recommending books that don't get much traditional media attention, with a special emphasis on foreign or translated fiction in her own reading life. I'm so excited to hear her recommendations along those lines today. I love this conversation with Lucy, and I think you will, too. Let's get to it.

Lucy, welcome to the show.

LUCY: Thanks so much for having me.

[00:03:41] ANNE: Oh, the pleasure's mine. This has been a long time coming, though you might not have known it. I really enjoyed your debut novel from 2018, What We Were Promised?

LUCY: Yeah. Yeah. It was a while ago.

ANNE: And I've been following your work ever since, so thank you so much for making the time to talk about your debut and your career and your book selling.

LUCY: Such an honor to be here. I obviously knew about you when you were helping to promote my book because I think it's every debut author's dream to get noticed by a real reader.

ANNE: No, not obviously. I had no idea. I feel like I'm just reading in my little chair and type things on the internet sometimes. Get to talk about readers, get to talk with readers on What Should I Read Next?.

LUCY: Yeah. Yeah, well, as a bookseller, I totally identify with being a reader first and a writer second, so I think this is perfect that we get to talk today.

ANNE: Ooh, I am eager to hear more about that. Okay, Lucy, we like to start our episodes by giving our listeners a glimpse of who it is they're hearing from. Can you tell us a little bit about yourself to give us a glimpse of who you are?

[00:04:47] LUCY: Sure can. I'm Lucy Tan. I am the author of two novels, What We Were Promised, as we said, came out in 2018, and Tiger's Mouth. Tiger's Mouth is my newest one. I had about a break of nine years in between the two novels. In that time, I also found another career in bookselling, and so I'm a bookseller at an indie bookstore here in Seattle.

ANNE: Ooh. Okay, so much to ask about book selling. How did you find your way into that profession?

LUCY: The story begins with my second novel, the novel that I wrote after What We Were Promised, which had a really promising beginning. I had written a chapter and submitted it to a fellowship, got the fellowship, which was hard to do in a field with a lot of applicants, and so very early on was getting funded to write this novel. And I started that fellowship the year that my first book came out, and I felt like I was all teed up for success, and that novel never sold.

[00:05:54] So I spent five years on that novel, and it was a quieter story about three young women who were best friends in Wisconsin in the regional theater world. I think the feedback was that it was too quiet of a story to follow up What We Were Promised, which got a good amount of attention and was well-reviewed but didn't break out sales-wise. And so my agent convinced me to pull my manuscript from submission and work on something a little flashier for my second published novel.

And so this was really difficult for me to sit with because I think it felt like a failure on one hand, but it also felt like not a true failure because we hadn't tried as hard as we could necessarily, and it was the first moment in my career where I had to choose between art and commerce. In the end, I decided to listen to my agent and think, "Well, can I write something that does both? Can I write something that hits hard on the market and is something that I can be proud of artistically?"

[00:07:03] That really brought me into this time of a lot of dread, and I was depressed for a while, trying to figure out, what am I trying to do here? And have I made the right career decisions, and how am I supposed to start writing again? It felt like what I was being asked to do was impossible. And so in that time, I was going very slowly. I was still writing, I never stopped writing, but I was really questioning myself. It was also kinda like the tail end when we were recovering from the pandemic.

Anyway, I was not in the best place when I walked into a bookstore in my neighborhood and applied for a job. I had friends ask me, "Are you going to be feeling negatively about working in this space and interacting with all these published books when your second book didn't get published?" And that wasn't my experience at all. It actually helped me write because I realized from watching booksellers sell books that it doesn't matter if your book is the most marketable, the biggest hit, the bestseller, because that's not what the bookseller's job is to do, is not to sell one book over and over again to one type of customer. It's to find the perfect book for each customer at the right moment in their life.

[00:08:28] And it occurred to me that that is what I want to do. I just want to write the one book that will connect with the people it's supposed to connect with, which is what I started doing in the first place. And I didn't have to worry about necessarily writing that one big book that all publishers were going to want to buy. So I kind of gave up on that idea of how do I write timely and pacey and all these things?

Then finally I started to write a book that would become Tiger's Mouth, which ironically ended up being timely and pacey. So I don't know. I guess the directive got in my brain somewhere. But through working as a bookseller, I was able to let my guard down and to push myself outside of my comfort zone, and to not get in my head about it, and end up doing the thing that I had been trying to do anyway.

[00:09:21] ANNE: I'd love to hear more about the bookstore. Can you walk us into the store and through the shelves metaphorically? I don't even know what to ask. I don't know if you're even able to access, like, how you thought about that world before you entered it because I imagine that you've now thoroughly incorporated bookseller into your identity.

LUCY: Definitely. Well, I'll start by describing Secret Garden Books as like your grandmother's treasure chest. You go in there-

ANNE: Sorry, that is a laugh of delight...

LUCY: ...nothing is organized.

ANNE: Yes, I love it. Keep talking.

LUCY: It's kind of cluttered, it's kind of dusty, but it's so happy. The vibes are impeccable. We get people who walk into our store, and they just inhale, and they just have a smile on their faces. There's a tax preparation place that rents the space above us, and for a while, there was this employee coming in on her break, and she would just stand there in the shelves and just be like, "It's so much happier here than it is where I am."

ANNE: It kind of is.

[00:10:27] LUCY: And she was one of my favorite people. You don't have to buy anything to take up space in a bookstore, I think, you know? I think a lot of times what makes a bookstore special to me is the people who linger and browse. So we get all kinds of people coming in, and we have all types of different books on the shelves. We, as booksellers, are more interested in fiction, so we have so many recommendations if you want to come in and read fiction. Trying to think how else to describe it. It's pretty relaxed, and cheery, and brightly lit, and warm.

ANNE: That sounds lovely. I imagine the answer is not compact here, but I'm so curious to hear how you've changed as a reader, and perhaps also as a writer, because of what you've learned in the store helping other readers find that special book that they can't wait to read next.

[00:11:15] LUCY: I definitely read more broadly now because I do buy for the store. I'm a buyer, which means that I have to have an understanding of what every kind of reader is looking for and hone my ability to recognize those elements in the books that we're bringing into the store, whether that has to do with cover design or topics that people are interested in, the sections that do well in our store genre-wise.

So in order to buy that way, I have had to read more broadly. That's a really good question. How has it changed my writing? It has broken down my understanding of genre. It has made me more open-minded toward different genres. I was previously straight in my lane of literary fiction, and now I'm reading more upmarket books. I am reading fantasy and trying to dip my toe into romance. That is the one genre I still have a little bit of trouble with. I think it has just made me more aware of the books that are coming out.

[00:12:25] The realization I've come to is coming from this literary fiction background, you have this idea that you want to write something that lasts the test of time. And so you're trying to write maybe subconsciously in this timeless way. But I think I realized that what actually becomes timeless is your artist mind coming into contact with the time in which it's producing. So a book that feels 2026 is going to be a marker of what it was like in 2026, and that can become timeless in its own way because it's a marker of where we've been and what one artist's experience of that part of history was like.

ANNE: That's so interesting. Lucy, when you say that you thought of yourself as a literary novelist for a long time, can you describe that for our readers?

[00:13:22] LUCY: Yeah. You know, it's a term that I still feel confused about as well. I think that for different people it means different things. If you ask my agents, they're kind of allergic to the word literary because it implies low sales. It implies that it's highbrow and that the readership is not going to be very big, and so the book isn't going to break out on the market. From an academic standpoint, literary fiction is fiction that is meant to be studied, meant to be spent time with, one that prizes the quality of writing and a sentence, the beauty of a sentence over the plottiness of a book or the commercial appeal. That's how I'm loosely defining literary fiction.

ANNE: I appreciate that, thank you. Now, you mentioned that as a bookseller and book buyer, that's a big job, that you have really embraced reading more broadly. I would love to hear what it is that you do enjoy reading. Not just enjoy reading, but what are you reading? How do you decide what to read next? What kind of books do you like to recommend to your readers? It's all on the table. Pick up whatever you want there.

[00:14:34] LUCY: Well, I always read what I am just instinctually drawn to. I don't really question, I don't have a TBR where I'm like, "Then I have to read this, then I have to read this," because the last thing I want is for reading to feel like a job. Right now, I still really love literary fiction. Books that I love place characters at their center. I think what I'm most interested as a reader and as a writer is the human experience. So any book that places the human experience in the center, as well as human relationships and how strange and weird they are, that I think is a big element for me.

Also, surprise is a huge element for me. It doesn't mean that the book has to be very plotty or have these bells and whistles and fireworks going off, but from a moment-to-moment experience, am I surprised or do I know what's going to happen? So, for example, a book that recently I read that really surprised me was Audition by Katie Kitamura. And this is about as literary highbrow as you can get. And it doesn't offer any easy answers. You may read the book and think, "What was that about," right? But it allows you the opportunity to read it with a friend. I had a bookseller friend that I texted for two days nonstop about this book.

[00:15:57] ANNE: Oh, I believe it. Having read this, I can see how you could have done that, yeah.

LUCY: So you feel the same way about Audition?

ANNE: I mean, the talk about ability factor on Audition is so high, because there's no easy answers.

LUCY: No easy answers.

ANNE: I thought it was ambiguous. Maybe I just didn't understand, but it was ambiguous, and you didn't know what's happening.

LUCY: No, I agree. I think it is. It is meant to be ambiguous.

ANNE: I like it when an author takes a big swing.

LUCY: Me too.

ANNE: And that book felt like a big swing.

LUCY: Yeah, me too. I think the other thing that I appreciated about it is there aren't a lot of women writers who get to take those literary big swings like her. I think a book that I've been comparing it to in my head is Transcription by Ben Lerner.

ANNE: I haven't read that one yet.

[00:16:41] LUCY: Well, maybe it's unfair to compare the two. I just enjoyed Audition so much more. I guess I have a little bit of a chip on my shoulder when it comes to the way that women writers are handled in the media and in publishing, you know? Despite the fact that most readers are women, we have a specific genre called women's fiction, as though all fiction weren't women's fiction. I think it would be more accurate if they wanted to specify men's fiction, right? To be this female writer, they're always trying to capture these markets and... Anyway, it just feels to me like very few women are allowed to do what Ben Lerner does, but Katie Kitamura is. So that is another reason that I love to root for that book.

[00:17:35] ANNE: Well, it's funny, I believe you said that you love to read and recommend books that aren't getting a lot of media coverage but are worthy of being read and that so many readers would be delighted to stumble upon. And we hear from our listeners so often that they're looking for those undiscovered gems, which might be on their bookstore shelves, but they're not the ones that are all over their social media feeds and not necessarily on the front bestsellers table. And when I saw that you enjoyed that, I didn't immediately clock that women writers could often fall under there, and that is sad but true. You also mentioned that you really enjoy reading translated and foreign fiction.

LUCY: I do, yes.

ANNE: I know. We have some readers who would love to hear what you have been reading and enjoying. What draws you? What do you find in translated and foreign fiction that brings you back? You hinted at the element of surprise. One of my What Should I Read Next? pet theories is that surprise is something that often creates special delight, but also a lasting reading experience. It stays with us. But of course, what surprises you is personal.

[00:18:43] LUCY: I think that I love reading translated fiction because there is a context to the world in which it's set that I am unfamiliar with. So already there is an element of surprise baked in. And I love to understand what storytelling is from a different perspective nationally. In Western literature, we have a lot of the hero's journey, but that's not necessarily true in different parts of the world and during different times. Russian literature, Chinese literature, Japanese literature, there's a lot of stories in which things are happening to everyday people there isn't that arc necessarily, and those books do well there. And it's really interesting to me too to see what translated fiction works and doesn't work in America. Recently we have had so many books from Japan that are classified as cozy fiction. And it's a lot of cats and bookstores and living this quiet Japanese life that has spoken to American audiences, maybe in a sense of escapism or personal connection on an intimate level.

[00:20:02] I think many of these books have characters that speak with really intimate voices, so maybe that could be it. But I love coming across specifically translated fiction that sits in the upmarket fiction category when it reaches an American audience. A couple recommendations that I have there are. One, Women Talking by Jiang Yueran. She's a Chinese writer who has written a short, quickly paced, straightforwardly told, although bit of an unreliable narrator, about a nanny who is working for a wealthy couple and taking care of their kid, but the wealthy couple never appears in the story.

[00:20:58] The story opens really quietly. So they're about to go on a picnic, she and this kid, and the hired driver that works for the family is about to take them. Really innocent, nothing's amiss. And as each chapter goes on, the story becomes stranger and stranger, and who you think these people are are not quite what they actually are. And so what is revealed is a story that is not just a domestic tale, but it's one that involves politics. It involves what it is to be female in China. It gets at all these big topics in a way that is so compelling, and that has surprise at the center of the story.

[00:21:41] So I highly recommend that one. And I specifically recommend it to you, Anne, because I think of it in terms of its premise as really similar to my first novel, What We Were Promised, which is also about hired help within this wealthier family. This story is set in Beijing, whereas mine was set in Shanghai with expats, and this one, I would say, is the darker version of what I've written. But it's thrilling. It is so good. It's a quick read. So I recommend that one.

And then a book that is similar in its vein is called Sakina's Kiss by Vivek Shraabong, and it's set in India. But it's also this story of a family, a small family, mother, father, and daughter, where the daughter is temporarily missing, and they're trying to track her down. But there's something happening within the text of the book that is not immediately clear, and the narrator starts to reveal himself as somewhat unreliable. This story is mysterious, but it is also really funny. And so to be able to hit those different tones, it's extremely dynamic. I think that it just reveals a writer who's kind of at his highest powers. So I definitely recommend that one.

[00:23:08] ANNE: Okay. That sounds interesting. Lucy, I've heard you use the word "quiet" a couple times. We hear from so many read... One of my favorite episodes of the show was with author Susan Meissner, who came on with her reader hat on to talk about what makes a quiet story really compelling. I don't mean to be cheeky or contrarian since you've told us that your quiet novel isn't a genre, but are there any favorite quiet novels that you love and would like to recommend?

LUCY: So many. So many. There's a book called Strange Weather in Tokyo by Hiromi Kawakami. I'm in love with the voice of that book. It's just about this young woman who lives alone. She reconnects with an older... a teacher that she once had, and they begin this relationship that defies categorization. And it's really just a story about these two people coming together at a moment in their lives where they need companionship. I mean, it's just a book that spoke to my soul.

ANNE: High praise.

[00:24:11] LUCY: There's a line, and I hope I don't butcher it, but... there's a line or a passage in that book that talks about... the narrator says that when she was in elementary school, she was an adult, and she didn't quite fit in. And as she grew older, she became more and more childlike, and she says that she guesses that she has never really been able to align herself with time. Something about that passage really resonated with me.

ANNE: You could think about that for years. And it sounds like maybe you have.

LUCY: Yeah.

ANNE: I see readers and writers talking about reading like a writer, like it's a good thing and something to aspire to often, and I wouldn't argue with that. But I love that you talked about writing like a reader. I'm so curious about, you wrote this novel that you spent five years on. You decided you weren't going to sell it after all, and then I'm assuming, and I may be very wrong, Lucy, but I'm assuming that something happened or you had an idea or you had a burst of inspiration that made you want to start the book that became Tiger's Mouth. Would you tell us what actually happened there, how that actually unfolded?

[00:25:24] LUCY: I have always been interested in writing about class, as you can tell with my first novel, class and privilege, but I also have, in the past few years, been thinking more and more about friendship. I'm in my 30s, and I don't want children, and so I'm realizing that friends are going to be my chosen family for the rest of my life. And had been noticing in the media, as a person in her 30s, that there's so much that is served to you content-wise about parenthood and so little on friendship. So you go from in your 20s, you're served a lot of content about how do you manage your romantic relationships, how do you deal with men or women, how do you, you know, couple off, essentially. And then it's about how do you start this nuclear family.

But friendship doesn't get a lot of coverage comparatively. And I was thinking about the fact that you can have somebody who you met at jury duty and become friends with over the course of a few days, and you could have someone that you've known since birth, that you've been in each other's lives all that time, far longer than you've known your spouse, and both of those people could be called friends.

[00:26:46] I mean, people use "best friend" in many different ways, but the idea of a friend is so vague, and I wanted to write about a vague friendship, and I wanted to write about all the different phases one particular friendship could go through. And I thought, "Wouldn't it be interesting if you had had friendship intersect with class and test the waters in terms of whether or not two people can be really close friends across class lines?"

So I made up two characters. I made them as different as possible. I called them both Jack because I wanted to highlight that there were some big differences, but also that they were traveling similar paths in life. And so the book starts where they intersect for the first time. And so this one kid who has not much to his name, working class kid from Queens, super ambitious and charming, he finagles his way into this prestigious internship that he really wants and happens to be office mates with the son of the CEO who has no desire to be there. He's got connections and pedigree and all this, but he's deeply depressed. And the two kind of connect in a really unexpected way.

[00:28:04] And so that friendship was really what propelled the novel. Then in order to up the stakes, I wanted to give them an opportunity to fight for, right? So they're both going after the same opportunity. Like, what happens then? So I really wanted to kind of test the boundaries of this friendship and also explore what a friendship could become and what's the line between friendship and family.

ANNE: I hear from so many readers who want to read tales of friendship. A platonic love story is a phrase I keep hearing. Though interestingly, when I was thinking about Tiger's Mouth and the two Jacks in this book, I realized that I've never heard platonic love story applied to a story about men. When I'm reading a book, I often just take it as it is, let the story wash over me. But now talking to you, I'm wondering how your desire to write about men may intersect with what we're reading about male friendship and the state of it today. And I will let you fill in all the blanks or correct me if I'm way off base, but please tell us everything.

[00:29:12] LUCY: There's two ways of answering the question, the way of answering it when I was actually doing it, which was entirely based on instinct. I mean-

ANNE: The same way you pick your books.

LUCY: Exactly. So I think that the back of my brain is sending signals to the front of my brain to do things without realizing it. So the way that I would have answered the question, if you were asking me in the moment, is just that I had a second novel that I wrote that didn't sell, and in it were so many women. It focused on women. The main characters were all women, and I needed a different energy. I wanted to write about men. So I think that's one answer to the question.

The second way of answering this question is, looking back, I do think that I was doing something strategic here in regards to story. There's a way in which I think that a friendship between two men is higher stakes. I think women are more practiced at forming these social connections. You know, I can sit down with a woman that I get along with, and she's going to know all of my deepest, darkest secrets within an hour or two.

[00:30:18] That's just not how I think it works between men. I don't want to say that as a blanket rule, but from what I've observed, not only in real life but in the media, the way that it's portrayed as men spending time together is at a ball game. They're facing away from each other. If they're talking, it's when they're looking at a video game screen or a TV. And I do think that spending physical time together is the way that they gain familiarity beforehand, and also joking and, like, all these ways of getting more comfortable with each other before sharing the deep, dark secrets.

So that, I think, adds stakes and drama to a storyline because they're not giving it all up that easily. They have these secrets that they keep from each other. So in the story, these two young men, even though they're drawn to each other immediately for various reasons, they're not entirely honest with each other about many, many things. That secret-keeping is what propels the story forward in a sense.

[00:31:27] ANNE: That's so interesting. That isn't the only way that this story feels so timely. So you're writing about friendship, and we haven't quite touched on this yet, but also loneliness. The male loneliness is big in this story. But also, artificial intelligence is huge in this story, privacy and tech. We have a nepo-baby in this story. You mentioned Jack Chen, who's just a real charmer, but now I think I've started listing things I really enjoyed reading about in this story. What I'm noticing is I imagine that because things have changed so fast with AI, it feels like, to me, not a tech-savvy person. I mean, I can use the tools, but I don't understand how they're created, woke up one day, and all of a sudden we have, like, AI everything being shoved in our faces, on our screens. And that changed so fast that that can't have been the world that you were writing this book in.

LUCY: No, no.

ANNE: But it's really launching at a moment where this is on all our minds, and the characters of the two Jacks. Not just the Jacks. There are some great women in this story, too, and at least one really terrible man and sympathetic characters who make... how about understandable but terrible decisions? But the strong characters and also plotty, pacey... I don't want to reduce it down to, but it's such a good recipe. Not that that's how writing works, you know? It's not like you have a formula or a list of ingredients, but it did work out so well for this reader. Yes, please say more.

[00:32:56] LUCY: I think that it's a combination. When you're writing, I think part of it is just facing the blank page and trying to be as audacious as possible and trying to find the story worth telling. But in the editing process, there is a part of... the left side of your brain that is making these connections, that is trying to choose, "Okay, of what I have here, what do I want to be the central through line of the story, and what themes do I want to address?"

I think when I was writing this story, we mentioned before that friendship stuff came up, but also my anxiety around AI came up. At the time, I mean, I actually don't remember what year this was, but What We Were Promised was one of the books that was used illegally to train AI. So obviously that's at the forefront of my mind as a writer is, how far is this going to go? How much of my work is in jeopardy because of this thing that I have no control over?

[00:34:02] And it's interesting because we call it an AI tool, but none of us has asked for AI to be produced in this way. It's just a few people at the top of these tech companies that have decided how we've invested so much money in this technology, in AI, how are we going to return our investors' money? So how can we profit off this? How are we going to get the majority of users to be using AI? And their solution has been, "Well, we'll shove it at them from every direction. We're going to include it in products without necessarily their consent. We're going to opt them in, and then we're going to start charging them for it. And very slowly, we're going to just kind of make people dependent on this thing that they never asked for," right?

And so I'm not against AI as a concept. I think that there are such better uses in the worlds of healthcare, and technology too, but I think the main thing that I was worried about is that it's these few people making these decisions with very little oversight, and we just don't have the regulation in place for laypeople to be able to have a say in how these products are being developed. And it's affecting our everyday lives in terms of data centers, environment, our attention spans being shredded. It's taking our very critical faculties.

[00:35:26] You don't have to decide to use AI. In a sense, you have to decide to not use AI. And I think that is what's so creepy, is that never before has passive behavior as a consumer opted you into something that has the power to sort of change the way that we operate as humans. And so I think when I was writing this book, I was not only thinking about what it meant for me artistically, but what does it mean when people's lives are at stake from a healthcare perspective, right? And so my mind was going to the worst possible scenario.

And on top of that, I had listened to this NPR interview with Dr. Joy Buolamwini, who wrote this memoir called Unmasking AI, and it's a story about her as a data researcher at MIT coming across evidence of algorithmic bias within facial recognition software that was being created. It revealed that software was trained on a data set that was primarily comprised of the faces of white men. And so the ability for facial recognition software to accurately detect faces is much more skewed towards White men and are falsely identifying or not identifying at all the presence of Black faces, people of color, women. It's just worse at it. This wasn't public knowledge.

[00:36:50] Anyway, this kind of kicked off a career for her as an activist, trying to ensure that there is some form of auditing happening for the models that are released into the market. And so this really jogged my imagination, and I thought about, well, what if something like this were to happen within the world of healthcare?

ANNE: Which is what happens in the book, and I'm just hearing how you harness that anxiety. You know, it never occurred to me that an author of a literary novel might be asking themselves, "How can I be as audacious as possible?" But gosh, it made for a good story.

Would you tell readers a little more about the kinds of themes that you wanted to wrestle with in this book, and the kind of questions that you are fascinated by?

[00:37:36] LUCY: Yeah. You know, I was really interested in the concept of the self-made man. And there's two characters in my book that identify with that. One is the CEO billionaire. He is somebody who also came from a working-class background, but really kind of clawed his way up the social ladder, the financial ladder, and has, quote-unquote, "made it." The other character is this Chinese American kid who also comes from a working-class background, and he has to fight other systems of oppression to get to a place of power or what he considers to be power. And he wrestles with the question, "Is there even a place for me at the top in the best-case scenario?"

It was important for me to have two characters identify with this trajectory, one you root for and one you don't root for, because I think that makes the... It makes the book more complicated. I always want to write books that ask questions rather than provide answers. I'm aiming to write books where book clubs will be happy to discuss this until dawn. I never want to write a book where it's like, "Well, this is what the author thought, end of story," because I don't think anyone really cares what I think.

[00:38:57] I think that the reading experience is what happens where text meets a human brain, and the beautiful thing that blossoms out of that. I think that's the experience that stays with people. And so me writing a book is the initiating moment for a relationship. I think every reader's experience is unique and beautiful and different. And this is why we keep coming back to books. This is why we want to talk about them with each other.

ANNE: Ooh, I also love a book that serves as a conversation starter. It still has something to say, but also doesn't keep the final word for itself.

LUCY: Right. Like a book that is like, "Look at this. I want you to look at this deeply. What do you think?"

[00:39:45] ANNE: Yeah, yeah, yeah. I love that kind of invitation. It feels so hospitable. As we both referenced, at the heart of Tiger's Mouth are two... there are, I think, 22 at the beginning of the novel, software developers. And I appreciated how you kept the programming conversations at... I was never over my head. I'm only realizing now. I understood what was happening. Thank you very much for that, as I'm not a tech person. But I also really enjoyed, perhaps accidental or not, the analog contrast of the ancient Chinese strategy game of Go in the book, which I had heard of, but I'd never Googled the formations one might play until reading this story. Would you tell us a little bit about Go and its role in the story, and how you knew it belonged?

LUCY: Definitely.

ANNE: I love a deep symbol, and I probably didn't know enough to fully appreciate it. But I mean, talking about hospitable books and that give you lots to ponder and explore.

LUCY: I should say I also am not an expert on Go. My personal relationship with Go is that my dad loves Go. I'm an only child. I grew up loving wanting to play games so badly, but I didn't have anyone to play with, and the only game he would really play with me was Go. So imagine I'm like 13, trying to learn a really high-strategy game. I think the reason it hasn't taken off as much in the States is because it's so high-strategy. It's more complicated strategy-wise than chess is. So it's been difficult to really find its market here. But he loved it.

[00:41:28] One thing that I did learn from him, and the reason that my dad loves it, is because it is pure strategy. You cannot make a passive move in this game. Every move that you make is in pursuit of your enemy or in defense, and ideally both. I love that as a symbol for Tiger's Mouth because that's the structure that I wanted for the book. I wanted it to be fast-paced, as we've already said. I wanted it to be this story of competition between two men, and I wanted everything that one person did to affect the other in some other way. So even when the characters are not in each other's lives, everything that they do, they're thinking about, what is the other person doing? And that is very much how Go is as well, this requirement that it has of the player to either attack or defend or both. It's not a game where you can sit back and let luck determine what happens.

[00:42:36] ANNE: That's fascinating. At what point did Go enter the story? Because now as I flip back through what happens in the novels, I can see how interdependent everyone's moves are. What a test for yourself as a writer to be, I imagine, thinking to yourself, like, "Does this push all the levers I need it to push in order to stay here and serve its purpose?"

LUCY: Well, from a plot perspective, before I had any thoughts about theme or symbolism, I needed a way for my two main characters to become friends. And like we said earlier, it's not that easy, right? You meet somebody for the first time who's from a totally different social class in a competitive environment. What's going to be the thing that allows them to spend time together that doesn't have to do with work? And I thought, "Well, these are two really smart guys who have engineering in their blood. Maybe they play Go." And so then it's this moment for the characters to surprise one another. So from Chen's perspective, he's like, "Oh, this white kid knows how to play Go. How strange is that? He's actually really good at it."

[00:43:49] Jack Chen previously had been this character feeling super not at home at work in, you know, company of all these wealthy people, but here's the wealthiest person, the most well-connected person. And when he has free time, he's doing a thing that I grew up doing, and so it's really attractive to Jack Chen. From Jack Owens' perspective, "Hey, here's a thing that I do by myself quietly that doesn't require me to reveal any part of myself, which I'm uncomfortable doing, and here's this guy who's willing to do that with me." It was a way in for both of them.

ANNE: That is fascinating. That's fascinating. I love that. I noticed what you said about the outsider and finding a way in, and I just really love the way that you write outsiders and shape-shifters and ways people seek to be at home in an unfamiliar world or win people over. I just really enjoy that.

[00:44:44] LUCY: Thank you. I have always identified as being an outsider for whatever reason. I think it's a core part of the way that I approach points of view in writing. So when I write from a character's point of view, I'm thinking actively: what about this situation that they're in is surprising to them and does not align with their expectations? Because I think as a person going through the world, the thing that we usually notice is the thing that doesn't align with our expectations. And maybe it's because I write from that perspective that it feels like everyone that I'm writing is, in their own way, an outsider.

ANNE: I'm realizing now how I felt very at ease in your story, and yet your characters in the... I think they're all written close third, they don't seem at ease in their worlds, hardly ever.

LUCY: No. Who is in their 20s, though, right?

ANNE: Oh, tell me about getting inside the mind of 22-year-old boys. The story unfolds over eight years-ish?

[00:45:50] LUCY: Yeah, about that. I think nine.

ANNE: Okay.

LUCY: Right? It starts in 2013.

ANNE: So they're not 20, 22... No, they're not 22 years old. 2021 the whole time, but that's where we begin.

LUCY: Well, I didn't start out thinking, "How am I going to get into the minds of 22-year-old boys?" I have known 22-year-old boys. I used to live in New York City. I don't know if I have a better answer than that. I didn't do any particular research. I think it's a lot to do with imagining the way someone moves in a room. A lot of it is rooted in dialogue. I'm obsessed with dialogue. I love writing what people say.

ANNE: I love reading dialogue. That's what that laugh is.

LUCY: Do you? I mean, what do you think is the pleasure of it for you?

[00:46:32] ANNE: Oh, I don't know, but you could hear I had a visceral reaction to it just then. I love it when the characters feel right and true, and also interesting. Right and true, and also have me leaning in, like, "Well, what are you thinking? What are you going to do?" And I love it when an author shows me what's happening in their heads, and also what's coming out of their mouths, and how that either is in sync or is not.

LUCY: Absolutely. I think I often come at writing from the point of view as an actor. And as an actor, when you have a script, you have to figure out what someone is thinking, which is usually different from what they're saying. Their motives are usually different. The thing that they mean is rarely the thing that they say. And I think that that contrast makes reading dialogue, for me, really, really interesting because it involves subtext and is just more engaging to read because of that.

[00:47:32] ANNE: Now, here I was assuming that writing inside the mind of a 22-year-old boy would be the hard part, and it sounds like that came relatively easily because of your, I don't know, inborn skills, your professional training, whatever it was. What parts of this novel were more taxing to get right?

LUCY: Well, you know, there were parts that I was much more nervous to write. I have a character with Down syndrome in the novel that I wanted to do justice, and personally, I don't know anyone that well who has Down syndrome. So that took a lot of research. At the end of the day, I feel like you just have to do your best and take a swing because the alternative is not including people with different experiences.

I was nervous about that. I was obviously nervous about the technology aspect because that's also a lane where I'm not an expert. Research has always been intimidating to me. But I think that the understanding of how people operate, like how 22-year-old boys operate, that has never felt like a challenge to me, not because I think I'm doing it right, but because what I have always done. I think what defines me as a writer, that defined me as a writer when I was seven years old, is this compulsion where I imagine myself into the mind of whoever's in front of me.

[00:48:54] So I'm always imagining what somebody's thinking, whether you are a woman or a man, whether you are an adult or a child. And that has always been the way that I write and get into characters, is this act of imagination. And I'm not more confident that I'm correctly imagining what a woman is thinking versus a man, even though maybe I should be since I am a woman. But I think that people are so complicated that it would be a disservice to look at a person and think, "Well, you're a man, and what would a man think?" Because to be a man is mostly a social construct, right?

So what I'm imagining is the way in which society has told you that you should be, and that's tough. You know, I grew up seeing in the media all the time, and I'm kind of watching that play out in front of me in classrooms, in workplaces. So it didn't feel unfamiliar to me, even though I think readers might feel like, "Well, that is such a different perspective from which to write. It must be a challenge." And so I guess the answer is it is, and it isn't.

[00:50:03] ANNE: That's fascinating to hear about. Thank you. I'm wondering how, if someone walked into Secret Garden Books and said, "Oh, Tiger's Mouth, I've heard of that. Tell me about it," what would you say? Is that impossible to answer about your own book?

LUCY: Well, it's more that I'm trying to figure out if I'm going to give you the three-sentence spiel or the one-minute spiel. But I've already done the one-minute spiel. So I would say it's a story about friendship and ambition and class. It's about two friends that become rivals, and it's fast-paced. I think it's a story that's easy to sink into. And in a market that I do think is primarily geared towards women, I think this is a book that invites male readers in a way that not all books do.

ANNE: If I overheard that three-sentence spiel at the bookstore, I'd want to be like, "What? What's she talking about? What's she talking about?"

[00:50:58] Lucy, I'm a big believer in reading every word of a book. I want to see what you choose for the epigraph and who you dedicate it to and also who you thank in the acknowledgments. And you said something that really intrigued me in your acknowledgments, that you were really grateful to the person who asked you, "What do you want your career to look like?" And I inferred that that meant that whatever that contemplation question brought up for you was valuable. But I'm so curious, what do you want your career to look like? On the launching of Tiger's Mouth, what do you hope for in the future?

LUCY: You even bringing that up has made me feel emotional again. I think that... The sad truth is that when she asked me that, I didn't have an answer because I had never really allowed myself to dream that big. I think for me it's always about can I publish the next book? Will it do well? And will that afford me the opportunities to further my career? Without really thinking about, well, what does that ideal career look like.

[00:51:57] I mean, I think if I'm dreaming as big as possible, I want it all. I want to have an international readership, I want to win awards, I want to be taken seriously. I want to be able to be artistically bold. I want to try different genres and not really be hemmed in by any concerns other than what I'm interested in. So I think that would be my ideal answer.

ANNE: Well, I'm so glad that you have been encouraged to dream big, and I hope that your writerly dreams come true. I'm so glad to have this book in my hands. I wonder if there might be a future for the female friendship novel. Do you have any idea?

LUCY: Oh, you know what? I'm glad you brought this up again because I have not revisited that novel in quite a while. So to me, I don't know how I feel about it, you know? We have spent this episode referring to it as the book that didn't sell because it was too quiet. But I don't know, maybe there are other things about that book that weren't clicking with readers. I'd have to go back and look to see how I feel about it as an artist now.

[00:53:07] ANNE: Well, wherever the future takes you, I'm excited to read whatever you put out next, and I'm just wishing Tiger's Mouth and you all the success in the world as this book makes its hand into the way of readers who will be, I hope, very glad to connect with it. Thank you so much for coming on today to talk about Tiger's Mouth and about your work and about your book selling, all the things.

LUCY: Thank you. It has been a pleasure.

ANNE: Hey readers, I hope you enjoyed my conversation with Lucy Tan. Find out more about Lucy and her books, including how you can get a signed copy of Tiger's Mouth, at her website and on Instagram. We have all those links, plus the full list of titles we talked about today, at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com. Find our show and follow us on Instagram at @whatshouldireadnext.

[00:53:59] Another great way to keep up with what's new each week is by joining our email list. Sign up at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com/newsletter. Make sure you're following in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Overcast, Pocket Casts, wherever you get your podcasts. Following or subscribing to our show helps us show up for new listeners looking for podcasts like ours, and it tells our advertisers and platforms that you enjoy what we do and want to keep hearing from us each week. In other words, it helps us a bunch. Thanks in advance.

Thanks to the people who make this show happen. What Should I Read Next? is created each week by executive producer Will Bogel, Media production specialist Holly Wielkoszewski, social media manager and editor Leigh Kramer, community coordinator Brigid Misselhorn, community manager Shannan Malone, and our whole team at What Should I Read Next? and Modern Mrs. Darcy HQ. Plus the audio whizzes at Studio D Podcast Production.

Readers, that's it for this episode. Thanks so much for listening. And as Rainer Maria Rilke said, "Ah, how good it is to be among people who are reading." Happy reading, everyone.

Books mentioned in this episode:

• What We Were Promised by Lucy Tan
• Tiger’s Mouth by Lucy Tan
• Audition by Katie Kitamura
• Transcription by Ben Lerner
• Women, Seated by Zhang Yueran (*Please note that Lucy Tan referred to this title as Women Talking)
• Sakina’s Kiss by Vivek Shanbhag, translated by Srinath Perur 
• Strange Weather in Tokyo by Hiromi Kawakami, translated by Allison Markin Powell

Also mentioned:

• Secret Garden Books
• Please support our sponsors.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We appreciate a good conversation in the comments section. Whether we’re talking about books or life, differing opinions can enrich a discussion when they’re offered for the purpose of greater connection and deeper understanding, which we whole-heartedly support. We have begun holding all comments for moderation and manually approving them (learn more). My team and I will not approve comments that are hurtful or intended to shame members of this community, particularly if they are left by first-time commenters. We have zero tolerance for hate speech or bigotry of any kind. Remember that there are real people on the other side of the screen. We’re grateful our community of readers is characterized by kindness, curiosity, and thoughtfulness. Thank you for helping us keep it that way.

Fall Book Preview

Refresh your TBR without feeling overwhelmed

Your Fall Book Preview is a 12-page lookbook of the books you’ll want to know about releasing September -December 2026.

a gateway

to reliable joy this summer

Our 15th Summer Reading Guide is coming May 14th.  Pre-order now and plan to join us on May 14th for Unboxing—the best book party of the year!

Buckle Up!

It’s almost time for the Summer Reading Guide. Order now and plan to join us on May 15th for Unboxing—the best book party of the year!

summer reading starts May 16th

Grab your Summer Reading Guide and join us for the best book party of the year!